Showing posts with label e-learning blended learning technology technologies kineo totara mahara boxing moodle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label e-learning blended learning technology technologies kineo totara mahara boxing moodle. Show all posts

Wednesday, 28 August 2013

All Support is not created equal

When I first started consulting in learning technologies my role seemed focussed entirely on implementing Learning Management Systems (LMSs) for organisations.  The aim was always for a smooth change management piece that brought in a new piece of vital learning technology into the organisation and the target was always to get the project 'across the line'.  Over the last couple of years, I've noticed a shift that means that whilst the line is still there, the focus needs to shift well beyond that line.  In short, ongoing support now accounts for the vast majority of what we do in the learning technologies space.

The issue is that if I call it 'support' what does that actually mean?  Support obviously comes in a variety of shapes and sizes (not to mention costs!), from a very low-level forum type support to tier 1 support where any user in your organisation can speak directly to the supporting organisation and even strategic consulting and high-level support. From a customer perspective what can you expect from your supporting organisation and what are these type of support?

At Kineo Pacific we offer 3 standard levels of support Gold, Silver and Bronze - but actually that alone tells you nothing except there are 'levels' and Gold will be the top one!  Instead let me describe quickly what the real things that distinguish levels of support (you can work out which of our levels they fall under for yourself if you want to - just ask me for our documentation!).

Below are some types of support.  These are neither exhaustive or exclusive and most good support packages will have elements of more than one of these.

Community Support.  It would be easy to write off community support as an ineffective and long-winded way of getting help (and sometimes it's exactly that too), but a product that has an established user base can sometimes offer some really great help.  A couple of examples spring to mind here; Moodle is one as it has a very well established user base (Moodle actually accounts for about a quarter of ALL LMS implementations globally) and there are lots of willing people sharing about it.  The problem comes in that it's a bit like searching on Google… it's really easy to search for something if you know what you're looking for.  The other issue is that a large number of enthusiastic amateurs can really send you off down some uncomfortable rabbit holes.  Another good example of community support is the Articulate community; this is a different type of support group with more support from Articulate than just users, but they have clearly invested in it and it does provide useful sources of information for users.  The problem with community support of course is that it relies on the community and often as not leaves you feeling pretty frustrated for anything beyond obvious issues.

Tier 1 Support.  This is the 'help desk' support where your own users don't turn to you as the expert but use third party support from your supplier instead.  We do this with some organisations that want to offer their LMS for external users and simply don't have the administrators or expertise to look after all the potential issues external users may have.  This type of support is great if you don't have any in-house expertise or time and although it's usually quite expensive it's often cost-effective when compared with the costs of employing a full or even part-time administrator to do the job.  We tend to call this administration rather than support, but the reality is it is still a form of support - just more direct.  Typically this type of support is accessed in a ticketed manner either by call, email or web interface.

Tier 2 Support.  The bulk of support plans fall into this category; it's about the supplier being there to help your organisation by supporting your key people rather than the whole organisation.  For an LMS this usually means getting support for your Systems Administrator, L&D personnel or trainers and system owner.  Ideally this will be ticketed or system controlled so you can find out what is going on!  A tip for the top is to limit the number of people able to access the support as most of these type packages are usually measured by 'hours' of contact and you don't want to find that some 'enthusiasts' have used up all your support whilst your key staff are left needing more for the actual vital areas of the business.

Real-time, Rapid, Standard, Slow… Okay, these may not be the actual labels given by the supplier, but there are varying levels of support response you can expect.  Real-time essentially means you can pick up the phone at any time and get help.  Not a recording or a logging but instantly.  Whilst this sounds great the actual reality is that you will pay a lot of additional money for something that usually isn't that necessary.  Don't get me wrong if we're talking technical support and keeping your LMS up and running then that's pretty much what you'd expect (99% plus uptime), but for the support of using an LMS then that's a different matter again.  "Quick it's a learning emergency, is there a teacher in the room!" is not something you'll likely hear to often.  All jokes to one side there shouldn't be too many emergencies in the administration of your LMS or much training on it (again, except those of a technical nature) so the need for real-time support is generally quite low.  You could reasonably expect some level of same-day support though as this can prevent having to continually wait days to get anything done.  Our 'normal' support sits around half-day and rapid around two hours - but generally it's much quicker.  The other good thing to note is that support is always instantaneous then the supporting organisation is not working with other clients or you have a dedicated support just for your organisation; that means that they may not be spending much time working with clients on their problems and therefore upskilling themselves and staying up-to-date on the system.

Local Support.  Is it essential to have support in the same city, country or hemisphere?  Certainly language barriers can prove an issue to support, but whether or not you need your supporting organisation in the same country depends on several factors.  I've worked and trained with clients from Australia, UK, US and here in New Zealand.  The only difference between any for me has been the ability to go 'on-site' and face-to-face.  For a couple of the organisations that really wasn't necessary with the modern tools at our fingertips but if you as an organisation need local support then you should clearly opt with an organisation as close to you as possible - at least with a presence in your market and general area.  You'll find the time zones can make a big difference too of course!

High-level Support/Consultancy.  So getting support for your administrator is one thing, but who is there to support you if you're the higher level manager?  Support doesn't necessary mean 'how do I do this?' and in fact the higher level support goes much further to look strategically at how we handle updates, changes and even internal issues that may affect the learning across the organisation.  If this seems like a consultancy piece it absolutely is, and I believe that consultancy is an important part of consultancy that can make an enormous difference to an organisation and yet is often completely overlooked.

Escalating Support.  I think it's vital in any relationship that there's some clearly defined roles.  Whilst the relationship between the support individual or team and the organisation's team or administrator, there's also higher levels of relationship that need to exist - even if they're not really involved beyond existing.  I think it's vitally important that if you're engaging support that there's someone you can turn to above the individual that you normally engage for support.  Our structure has three basic levels that usually cover our needs; from day-to-day support staff to consultants and a level above - whether you refer to that as the relationship manager or simply the manager of the consultants is probably semantics, but it's great that managers in the organisations we support can find someone to talk to when they're not getting the support or even the answers they need.

Feedback.  Okay, this isn't strictly part of the support, but it is part of the support agreement.  As a customer you could reasonably expect a level of feedback from the supporting organisation; how much support have you used and got remaining as a minimum, who is asking the questions and even a full breakdown of how time is spent.  It's also reasonable that a supporting agency would ask the question 'how are we doing?' - after all you'd expect that from anyone involved in learning right?

All in all a great support relationship is dependent on many things; ultimately a successful support arrangement is one you and your teams feel confident that you can do the tasks you need to and when you can't; well, there's someone there for you to help that you can rely on.  If not, best give me a buzz...

Friday, 20 April 2012

E-learning Boxing Match

Okay, so we can safely say this may not be the world heavyweight title bout of the e-learning world; but there's a definite issue that sometimes comes between where your money, time and effort goes with respect to your learning technology (such as your LMS or social learning platform) and the content or e-learning that generally sits on it (or would if you had one in some cases). Is this really an issue though? Surely one of these is just the tool and the other what really matters? Maybe.. maybe not.. perhaps one of these is like the players and the other one the referee; nobody likes the ref but try and have a good contest with a bad ref and it turns into a mess pretty quickly.

If you're new to this e-learning business the first real question you may encounter is where to start; with e-learning courses or somewhere to host them. This isn't always the issue, regularly
LinkL&D/Trainers find themselves making online material long before they know it's really e-learning (or saying they make e-learning when they put Powerpoints on the sharepoint - no, not a knock on the excellent Articulate Suite!). Whilst this isn't a planned approach let alone a true e-learning strategy it's kind of the way to go. This is not a simple chicken and egg scenario; having an LMS, even a cool one like TotaraLMS, is pointless without any content; in fact generally it's really a killer for organisations trying to change culture and introduce e-learning if there's no, very little, or very bad content on their system. The converse isn't quite true, you can put up some e-learning Flash modules on your sharepoint, you can put them in a shared file or even host them on a web-page if you know how - none of these are an LMS, but at least you can get to the content. It's kind of like buying a house without a garage and parking in the street; it's not ideal, but it will get you by initially.

Now this is a learning technologies blog so don't think for one second I'm conceding that easily to the content without at least a bit of a fight. That was the initial discussion and if you're in the early stages of the e-learning journey you definitely nee
d to think about how you're getting your content together ahead of the optimum method of delivery. That said if you go out and buy some classic cars where the badges cost more than my Toyota (not difficult in all fairness) you probably don't want to park them outside your local and hope they'll be okay. Again, this is a budget issue; if you have plenty of dosh to buy Ferrari learning packages (not literally, unless of course you're a car dealer..) you probably have plenty of money to waste on a corporate LMS or spend wisely on an Open Source one. Either way for my money, round one goes to the content.
Later round of the fight is where we quickly realise the frustrations of using something other than an LMS to manage our e-learning. The first point is as early as the 2nd round when the seconds come out and no-one can tell you the scores from the first round. Tracking is the single biggest killer of parking your cars on the street - after all, would you park them on a street if you didn't know where they'd be when you went back? So early in the piece you are going to need to invest in an LMS. The LMS of choice for small companies, educational institutions or anyone on a very limited budget is Moodle. Why? Simply it's very good if you're basing things around courses and don't need to have the world's greatest tools. It will launch and track e-learning and that's a great place to start. There's a reason it's used by more organisations than any other LMS; usability, customisability and of course, it's open source so doesn't carry the price tag of a corporate system. Round 2 definitely belongs to the technology; but wait..

Back bounces the content; we're now tracking away and launching our e-learning, but what have we got to show for it? The LMS is the system but as long as they can launch courses that's what really counts isn't it? If so, we must now spend time on getting those done (speak to Kineo Pacific here; we're real good - last plug I promise). The only way it's not a knock out at the mid-stage of the fight is that your LMS should be able to fight back with some authoring tools of its own; maybe not the cool clicking animation things, but certainly content like resources, web-page development and activities like quizzes and assignments etc. Buying or using an LMS with content development tools is a bit of a win-win, your instructional designers or trainers will be happy, but so will management if they have the tools they need.

Mid-way through the fight and content is on top again, is there anything the technologies have up their sleeve to force this fight on or should we concede? Maybe there is, what if you spent nothing or next to nothing on your LMS to enable content to be built and there's a few things it's missing that will make all the difference to your learning? Jabbing out with some dashboard controls and easier interface, firing some hard punches of being able to build custom reports, hooking away with performance management tools like individual learning plans and competency based training. Content can defend itself but the haymaker comes in the form of integration. Okay, that didn't pack the literary punch I was looking for but wait a second, if you put in place a simple cloud or stand-alone LMS what would an LMS that actually talked to the other systems that you use do for you? All your users, your hierarchies, your competency frameworks, your performance management and goals, even your reporting engine and records management. It's not about an LMS that does everything, it's about an LMS that talks with other systems to do everything together.

But somehow content stays on its feet. There's not really anything new in its approach, content is the slugger that won't stop advancing. In the technology world we've thrown everything we can at it. The only way to beat it lies in one last ditch attempt. Yes in order to stop the onslaught technology has to turn away from its roots and go back to face to face (apologies for the rambling mess of running metaphors and literals). So the extra power we need is in the blend. Your LMS needs to handle those workshops and face to face courses that your organisation used to survive solely on. By incorporating and enhancing workshops with management tools you have moved beyond e-learning and into blended learning where you always said you wanted to be. This has eliminated the defense of e-learning content and sets it open for the knock out..

Can social learning provide this.. self-generating content that doesn't have to be written.......

Okay, think I took the match too far. In all seriousness if your LMS takes up all of your budget something is seriously wrong - tweet or email me and we'll do something about that. Content is always going to survive and thrive, but don't underestimate the power of the technologies that are, like labour saving devices of old, there to make our job that much easier. The trick is finding the right technologies at the right price; again, choose your partner wisely.

As usual the opinions here are my own and more than likely some of you don't agree with them, that's cool I'd love to hear from you: @NigelKineo nigel.young@kineo.co.nz or nigelkineo.blogspot.co.nz