Friday, 24 October 2014

That Flipping LMS

I spend a fair bit of time (read too much) working with learning management systems (or LMS) and it's amazing how often people moan about their LMS.  Often there's good cause to moan with some of them being fairly awful (no naming and shaming here though) but sometimes it's because of the way people approach and use the LMS.  I work predominantly with open source LMS like Moodle and Totara and they're very flexible tools, but there's definitely a right and wrong way to do things with them.  Problem is most people see red and moan about the flipping LMS.

Not that I'm averse to original thought, but during a #lrnchat session I heard some great words of wisdom from Adam Weisblatt (a learning technologist a bit like me but more intelligement and all that) and checked his blog.  Well worth a read and he introduced a concept called the Flipped LMS... and that's where were at here; instead of moaning about the flipping LMS let's consider Flipping the LMS.

Hopefully some of you are aware of the Flipped Classroom approach which has really revitalised a lot of (desperately in need of a revamp) boring old lectures.  In a nutshell, the approach is that instead of trying to cram a lecture full of knowledge based learning and then give out assignments, the students get all the knowledge based stuff as pre-reading or research, then during the 'lecture' time they spend the time working on 'assignments' or problems.  If you think about it we reflect a lot of that in our good elearning these days with 'pull' elearning where you aren't force fed the knowledge part and you have to go and get what you need to know.

Well the flipped LMS is much the same principle.  The first idea is to recognise that there is knowledge beyond yours out there so we don't have to try and cram our LMS full of every piece of knowledge there is.  Let the learners go elsewhere to find the information and then come back.  Then your LMS is the focus of the assessments (the bits that are easy to track) and communication so that you can track what needs to be tracked.  It's a far less restrictive way of doing things and allows the learners much more freedom in their 'learning' and they can then use the LMS to prove what they have learned rather than trying to learn everything in the LMS.  It also fits much better into a pervasive learning model.  If you subscribe to 70/20/10 or a variant of such, it means that your assessment sits in that small piece of the pie - great for your LMS and great for your learners.

Thing is, calling it a flipped LMS is a bit of a misnomer.  The LMS is a tool that can be used in a variety of ways; some creative like this and others as a potential store of all the information.  It's not actually turning the LMS completely on its head, it's just about approaching it slightly differently.  Thing is, most learning is going to lie outside of your LMS whether you like it or not, so finding ways to embrace and maximise the opportunities should be your aim.

In short, flipping an LMS is like flipping a classroom; it's about maximising the effect of limited time or space with learners and recognising that the 'knowledge' piece is only part of the puzzle.

Thanks again to Adam and apologies if I've trashed your perfectly good ideas on the subject :)

Wednesday, 15 October 2014

Time to Upskill L&D

I’ve just spent the last few days in Melbourne with L&D peeps at LearnX and OzLearn chat and there’s a clear theme that I’ve picked up on through the time here; L&D people need to upskill to meet the demands of the modern environment.  This is in no way a knock on the skills or attitudes of the many good people who work in learning and development or people and performance or any other name for assisting with the learning function of organisations, but it should act to serve as notice that in order to effectively lead and manage learning functions in today’s world our L&D managers need to embrace learning technologies like never before.

Now you’d think this was maybe just me speaking as a clear advocate for learning technologies and, well, yes in someways it is, but the fact remains that there are still severe shortages in the workplace of those with an understanding of what’s out there and how it can benefit their people.  You wouldn’t catch it any other part of learning would you?  Can you imagine an L&D type person saying ‘I don’t do evaluations, I just don’t believe in it’ or ‘putting objectives on things just ruins it’ or how about ‘I don’t believe in face to face sessions’?  Of course not, our job in L&D is to make use of the right tool for the job, make sure we engage with sound instructional design and use everything in our toolset to help people learn and develop.  So if you don’t do learning technologies, or you don’t want to get involved in elearning let alone social learning or heaven’s forbid a MOOC (whatever that may be); then you’re probably not offering the best you can to your people in L&D.

Don’t get me wrong here, there’s a time and a place and I’m not suggesting that elearning replaces everything for your or any organisation (unless it really is the best tool), but you can’t ignore it all together.  Anyone who thinks that elearning is just a phase and is going away is as deluded as anyone who believes that face to face training is finished.  Sometimes nothing will do but having a facilitator, trainer or educator actually there with a group of people to enable the learning, but sometimes that’s not only unnecessary but the wrong thing altogether.  eLearning often makes its way into organisations because of the efficiencies it can present.  That doesn’t mean its not the most effective tool either, these are not mutually exclusive events.

I also don’t think that if you’re an L&D manager or advisor you must automatically be the world’s greatest elearning provider or technical guru.  I don’t think it’s realistic for everyone to go from no skill in the area to being a guru overnight, but you should be taking an interest in the area and gaining some experience along the way.  The Australian market is more mature than the New Zealand market (but both are immature compared to the UK and much of Europe, let alone the US) but in both those countries I’ve come across numerous L&D people who know as little about elearning as they do about nuclear physics (yeah, those of you who’ve read some of my earlier blogs now know about my past…).  I can understand an organisation still not having any elearning - it’s expensive business to get into and you have to look closely at the benefits and ROI before embarking in that direction; particularly if you’re a small organisation.  But for the L&D function to not even have looked at the options and what’s available is far harder to understand.

Not only is this a challenge to those in that boat (if they’ve read this far) but it’s also an offer to help.  I’m going to put some resources together for everyone to look at and also start bring in other areas off the web so that there can be no excuses moving forward.  On top of that contact me directly and I promise I’ll help where I can.  You can contact me via my LinkedIn profile (see the about me) or Twitter handle or email if you need more or engage me on any of the social media tools that form part of my daily work. 

We’re coming in to land now (yes, in flight blog again) so I’ve got to pack away the computer, but without wanting to sound too corny, it’s time for your  learning to  really take-off and make the most of the technologically accelerating world that we’re living in.

Monday, 13 October 2014

Games, Games, Games - Gamification and Learning


In the last few years much has been made of games playing and its connection to learning.  In fact gamification is as hot a topic as you get in the learning tech world and it’s been that way for the last couple of years.  The thing is, we need to understand that there’s a huge range of computer games ranging from the simple to the incredibly media rich and complex (not necessarily the same thing).  Some modern games look more live TV than they do computer generated and with the technological acceleration that we’re a part of it won’t be long before you won’t be able to tell the difference I’m sure (let alone true 3D).  The first computer game I had was tennis.  It didn’t resemble much in the way of tennis if I’m honest, it was more like two long thin rectangles (the racquets) on either side of the screen, a vertical line in the middle as the net and a little square s the ‘ball’; some ‘gamification’ used in learning hasn’t really moved past that - and I’m not suggesting that’s a problem, but we just need to be aware of gamification really means.

If your idea of gaming is Grand Theft Auto or commanding armies and building clans then elearning on the whole just won’t satisfy you.  This isn’t saying that you can’t have learning in games; I love to mess around on word type aps on my iPhone with a Scrabble or Scramble type base - sure I’m learning by potentially expanding my vocabulary - but here’s the important thing; what’s the intended take-away from playing Scramble?  If it’s to try to expand my knowledge of words then maybe it’s a great example of elearning.  If it’s to entertain me, then it’s not really elearning is it?  I mean, I may get some learning out of it, but that doesn’t necessarily make it elearning?  Or does it?  Play some first person shooters and they probably won’t prepare you to fire an automatic rifle or use a high-powered sniper rifle  - but they give you some understanding about military communications or basic tactics (and yes, these type of games definitely have a military application, particularly when paired with actual rifles).  Again, the difference between elearning and accidental learning maybe about intent - but again, does that matter?

Thing is, the games that are intentionally for elearning are often a lot more basic than these.  I’ve seen a good example of customer services software where the scenario plays out and your responses can change the responses of the customer in an entertaining way that could be classed as a game.  As a piece of elearning it was pretty successful.  It was engaging (certainly more so than ‘click next to continue’ learning), with some well-thought out scenarios and responses that realistic enough to make you want to play.  There’s  a good reason that gaming in learning is often limited to this type of scenario project rather than GTA style mega 3D graphics.  Money.  The games business is a huge multi-billion dollar industry.  People pay a lot of money to get their hands on the latest games, not to mention paying for the latest and best hardware to play it on and high-speed internet necessary to connect them to other like-minded individuals.  The elearning industry at the cutting edge end is big-business; but not for the likes of small and medium sized businesses and investing hundreds of thousands of dollars in the build of learning games has not been seen outside of simulators. 

That means that if you’re going to use gamification then you’re going to have to either take a step back or work for a company with a ridiculous budget for producing a game with true learning.  But taking a step back isn’t necessary a bad thing either.  The early days of gaming in some way were the most exciting; sure there were huge limitations with graphics and memory (16kB RAM pack anyone?) - now if that doesn’t sound like an elearning dilemma that we can relate to then I don’t know what does.  My favourite games in the early days were not the Jet Packs or the Manic Miners (yes, I’m really that old), they were the simplest of all games, the adventure games.  For those of you that can cast your minds back that far, the most addictive type of games I knew were text adventure games - for those not in the know they were called text, because there was absolutely no graphics (and then later the odd screenshot).  They felt like there was no ‘plot’ obviously there for you, you had to explore your surroundings and work out what to do, solve the puzzles and achieve whatever the subject of the game was.  Then there was the simple theme type platform game that was so simple and without the greatest graphics, but again it keyed into our basic desire of wanting to achieve something to get to the next level or get the highest score.

So if we’re talking gamification in elearning we’re probably going to have to be creative because we have to generate something in our learners similar to the type of feeling that those early games gave us.  Even some of the most recent successful games have been simple; whether your birds are angry or flappy the key is that they are addictive - that’s the whole point, you want to play them.  They’re like the cleverest type of objectives because they generate in the player a huge desire to keep playing.  If you could tap into that so that your learner just ‘had’ to keep learning, just imagine the potential!  Our aim as instructional designers is often focussed like a modern game on the way things look and how impressive they are and we sometimes overlook the simple addictiveness or learner needs.  Sure great looking graphics are a necessary part of design, but if your learning looks great but is really uninteresting it will be as unsatisfying as a bad game.  The worst game I remember from the arcades when I was growing up was one that used laser disks (big DVDs without the ability to store much).  It was beautiful with full TV type quality action that kept pausing and you had to do something.  In essence you could either move one way or the other by moving your joystick or leaning (if you had the simulator version) and then depending on what you did something would happen.  Take that back to our text adventure game and that’s the equivalent of you having to either say ‘move left’ or ‘move right’ and that’s it.  Boring.


The other thing about games that’s similar to learning is finding the right level of difficulty.  If a game is too easy there’s no competition and it needs to be really long to work (and your elearning budget may not stretch to really long), it needs to be enough of a challenge to make it worth completing - same is true of learning if you really want to test someone properly then it should be a challenge of doing (rather than just knowledge recollection or obvious choices).  I can’t help liking games where there’s a leaderboard so you can test out your abilities.  Would be quite cool if your elearning could do that too.  Imagine that passing was one thing but you devised a skill based trainer where there was a leaderboard for completing with both 100% accuracy and a time?  That would be cool.  Or an Angry Birds type game scoring where you needed to complete but got so many stars on each part - you could complete the whole learning with one-star in each part but you may want to go back and get three stars in each part.

Last thing I want to bring in is the idea of trial and error.  I know lots of you may not like the idea of trying something to see if it works and failing, then trying again, but growing up that’s one of the very important ways we learn things.  My old text based adventure games were built around that idea, you had to be innovative and not be afraid to fail - when you got it right and unlocked another area it felt real good.  In elearning that could be not front-loading your learning but starting with the game, letting people find out funny things that can go wrong and even try and improve their performance without totally knowing what they’re doing.  The sound design is obviously necessary to make sure that somewhere somehow we’re not only getting some success but learning about what we’ve done to get there.  I’d love to see more imagination in our elearning games, more challenging, more allowing for learners to get it wrong and still find a way to succeed in the end.

Okay, very very last thing (this is quite a long flight to LearnX in Melbourne if you’re asking).  Time.  Time may be the single most limiting factor when producing gamification in elearning.  Plants v Zombies the biology class version probably won’t be available next week, so again you’ll need to innovate - if you come out with something really cool, please let me know and if I like it I’ll chuck it up on my blog or website for others to see.

Happy Gaming :)

Monday, 6 October 2014

7 Steps to Stop Being a Control Freak


One of the worst things in the work place is a micro-manager.  Anyone who’s ever worked for one (and yes we all have at some point it seems) will tell you that taking away a person’s autonomy is a quick way to take the initiative and fun out of the work place.  Micromanaging is an example of controlling behaviour, a ‘control freak’ is exhausting in every respect and this includes your learning environment and learning itself.

So here’s a few simple steps to help you stop being a learning control freak:

1. Put yourself in the learner’s shoes  If you really want to ensure you don’t design your learning in a way that micromanages your learners then try it from their perspective.  If the learning feels constrained and limited then you’ve probably fallen into the trap of making it too restrictive.  Chances are if you don’t like doing it, no-one else is likely to either.  Go further and run your design through some neutral others.

2. Reduce the push  A very early blog of mine was on the concept of pull learning rather than simply pushing information to learners.  If you want them to have some feeling of control whilst doing the learning stop forcing everything upon them (push) and start allowing them to decide when they need more help and resources.  One of the frequent errors that designers make on elearning in particular is that they spend a lot of time putting together a resource and then decide because of the effort that went in to producing it then it should be the mandatory for the learner.  Regardless of how nifty your animation is or how long you spent creating a drag-and-drop example, if they don’t need it to reach the level then don’t force it on them.
 

3. Make it easy to start There may be nothing worse than learning that seems to require a Krypton Factor type problem solving ability to launch.  Try to reduce seventeen required clicks just to get it going and if you can find ways to easily drop out and rejoin then you’re definitely going to improve the experience.  Lots of learning systems and learning has too many steps to get going; this makes the learner feel like they have to jump through hoops for the sake of it and can really but a dampener on the whole affair.

4. Don’t make assessments too easy  It may not seem like an over-bearing idea to have easy assessments, but if you make someone jump through a bunch of hoops and at the end of it they have to answer true or false to incredibly simple questions (or multiple choice where three of the four are stupid answers) then you’ve confirmed their belief that you were simply wasting their time so that they could perform mundane tricks for you.

5. Don’t punish learners  I know it’s tempting to really want to hammer those damned learners when they get it wrong - but remain focussed on what your aim is here.  If you have set aims (if not, this is probably another simple step) then, like a good classroom teacher, remain calm and help them achieve the aim through another path.  For example, if you allow them to take the test at the start of the course, if they fail to achieve all the learning objectives that doesn’t mean you have to plunge them directly through all the media you’ve created just to make sure they get it.  I like multi-pathway learning where you try to provide a path to get to the end from wherever you are and remembering that learning is the path rather than the destination (sounds like a deep quote about life itself almost).

6. Allow learning outside of your learning  These days very few learning experiences are limited to what you’re taught simply in the classroom or elearning module.  Learning is pervasive and we need to allow for the learning to go beyond what has initially been designed; whether that’s allowing for assessments on the job, or further study or self-reflection or just some links and the ability to blog.

7. Make it fun One thing that can get forgotten in all of this is that learning is supposed to be fun (so is work if it’s done right after all).  Make your learning fun whenever possible, give people things to do and don’t forget that people will show more interest in things that they enjoy doing.

If all that fails you can just shout at them and tell them they must learn it :)

Friday, 26 September 2014

Erring on the human side and 7 steps to avoid it

I've notched up another year on the age scale today so forgive me if I'm in a fairly reflective mood.  As usual my blog is less about a planned and insightful look into the world of learning technologies and more random stuff as a result of a trigger that occurred through my work and/or life.  Today's inspiration comes from a stuff up that I made yesterday, but it contains a lesson that I thought was particularly relevant in technologies.

Anyway yesterday I made the not-so-subtle stuff up of including someone on the distribution list for a fairly sensitive email who the email was about rather than to. This type of error I fortunately don't make too often, but the outcomes can be really damaging to relationships and when you work in a relatively small market area (yes, we classify New Zealand that way).  This made me think a little on our communications and the way we do things as humans.  I knew who the email was about and wanted to include the relationship owner in the email.  Somehow I managed to not only include the relationship manager but also the individual... sigh.

The issue here isn't that uncommon and I'm sure at some point in our lives we've made the mistake of putting the wrong people down on communications and sometimes that can have massive consequences in the business world.  Why does it go wrong?  Well, largely it's because of the way our minds work - now I'm no psychologist, but we associate things and make patterns in our head that seem reasonable and we sort of go on auto-pilot - we do things without thinking in other words.  This strikes me as one of the most important reasons to spend time early in a technologies implementation to minimise the human processes.  The old expression goes that to err is human; effectively making mistakes is part of our make up (some of us even make it an art form), the argument here is that if we want to make less stuff ups we need to take 'us' out of the equation as much as possible and in particular the parts where we slide onto auto-pilot.

The simple rule is that whenever we can take humans out of the simple automation parts we do, because we are the ones more likely to make the mistakes.  It doesn't mean that humans don't make decisions because that's still a likely part of your learning and a great way to involve people in decisions that have the big impact, it just means that we take the monotonous tasks (where errors are most likely to creep in) out of the equation.  So if you're looking to reduce human error here's a list of my favourite ways of doing just that:
  1. Bring in your data from a single source of truth. Rubbish in = rubbish out.  If the information in the system is wrong you're starting in a precarious place.  So rather than manually put this information in, we look for ways to sync this information via a single source of truth (like an HR system or HRIS or Payroll system etc)
  2. Remove multiple sign-ins to systems. If possible rather than risk the wrong information when logging on we utilise single-sign-on (SSO) so that the user is automatically and seamlessly transferred from one system to another without getting the chance to get it wrong and sign-in as the wrong person or have to turn to support or helpdesk.
  3. Where decisions are automatic without need for subjectivity then automate them.  When we're setting up someone's learning environment I'm always on the lookout for things that we can set to happen on a rule based or logic type assignment.  For example in Totara when I'm looking at setting up audiences I like to look at what rule sets can be used to dynamically set up people so that they receive the right training, end up on the right courses and even see the right information in the system.  The reasoning here is simple, that I can still make mistakes, but by testing and running through those rules that set my audience up, I end up with an automated system that will logically and consistently apply the rules to make sure the right people are in the right places.
  4. Use dynamic rules.  Rules based on simple logic are great - even better if they are dynamic; that means that the rules get reapplied continually to change the way things are setup as the data changes.  This is the best way to have up to the second data in your reports and the right people in the right learning.
  5. Use dynamic links If we're linking and providing other information we look to set those links up in a dynamic way that change with the content rather than breaking.  There's almost no experience worse in the modern technology based world than a broken-link and you'll lose your target audience quicker than something that goes really quickly (sorry, slight loss of a decent metaphor).
  6. Invest in thorough testing.  Don't forget to never underestimate the ingenuity of fools when claiming something to be fool-proof. We sometimes work with clients who don't want to invest in thorough UAT (user acceptance testing), but this is a really important part before launching anything.  A 'Titanic' type failure on your launch is something you can't recover from so investing a decent amount of time for your own testing is really a must.
  7. KISS.  A great modern acronym for keeping it simple (there are a variety of ones for the final S if you find Stupid offensive).  Keep your systems as simple as possible, Boolean algebra is like any other kind of algebra in that it can often be simplified down.  It can be really hard to follow if you've not tried to do this or used a convoluted way around the problem.  Again working with someone else and explaining what you've done is a good check.

As a final note, I managed to right the email issue yesterday by immediately spotting what I'd done and owning the error.  Immediately I sent out an email to those on the list saying 'sorry' - I also spoke to the person who shouldn't have been on the list and did the same.  The most important thing when erring is to remember that it's what we do as humans; how we deal with the after-effects are what defines us as people.  When you get it wrong (there's really no 'if' about it) own the error.  I've said so many times before but in learning technologies as in life, it's all about ownership.

Friday, 19 September 2014

The Technological Acceleration

It's well known that we're living in a world full of technological change.  Most of us can look over our own lifetimes and see a remarkable change - for me I remember my first computer (ZX81 - thanks Sir Clive) and a wobbly 16kb additional memory pack, my record player that could play both sides of the record without turning over, my Philips original CD player, my Betamax video recorder and various other things that have advanced over my (relatively) short time on the planet.  In fact if you look back over the last few hundred years you won't see a gradual list of change; from the industrial revolution in the early 19th century to the massive scientific gains (communication, nuclear, birth of the internet) in the 20th century to the start of the 21st century.  In fact, this century is only just over a decade old and we've already seen an explosion in technology; led by the expansion and availability of high speed internet and the ever increasing mobility of technology - think Apple Watch and latest mobile phones.  There's a word for a rate of increase; it's acceleration.  We're a part of technological acceleration not just a fast-moving environment.
Scientifically acceleration doesn't mean fast; it means getting faster.  Of course from our relative perspective it's not quite possible to stand far enough back to see just how much things are getting faster, but look at your own lifetime.  In that relatively sort period things have come further than in any other period in the history of time of the same length.  That's not the scary thing about acceleration, the scary thing is that if left unchecked things that are accelerating get faster and faster.  If you apply a force in space to an object it accelerates (same as on earth of course), but without air to resist the acceleration it will continue to accelerate unchecked and get faster and faster and faster.  What this means to our technological world is that although 2014 may have seen some great changes (down to your computer on your wrist), 2015 will have more and you'll probably have as many changes in the first month of 2020 as we had this year.
Where does this leave learning?  If you're digging your heels in about all this learning technologies stuff and adamant that learning only takes place in a controlled environment like a classroom the chances are you're either already out of the learning world or you're heading that way soon.  Learning itself has evolved both in its theories and in its use of the technologies that are accelerating.  The issue for many organisations is that they feel they are behind the curve; no or very little elearning, no LMS or only basic functions used, no virtual classrooms, no social learning, or very little or very poor of any of that list.  In fact some organisations will use the speed of change (remember its actually accelerating) and their being behind as an excuse to actually hold fast.  Really?  The property market is racing away so the best thing I can do is not get on it?  It makes no sense to hold off from the changing world because it's changing, but what can you do?

For starters let's make sure that we're aware of what's going on and always looking for opportunities that will arise with the technological acceleration.  If we firmly fix our plans based on what was known ten years ago, or five or even two years ago we'll be unnecessarily checking our own progress.  Your strategies should not be about trying to set in stone something that's rapidly changing, but setting your attitude to how you handle that change.  For example, investing in research and development (or R&D) is no longer a luxury commodity, it's an essential part of core business.  Building R&D into all your key roles, changing your environment to one where your people are constantly on the look out for new opportunities, removing 'because that's the way we've always done it' from your workplace, looking inward, outward, forward and not just backwards.  For learning that means recognising that your learners are part of the learning too; they need to be a part of the process, part of the design of the learning, able to access 'stuff' when they want to, opening up your systems - maybe even losing a little control along the way.

If Change Managers were a necessary part of the late 20th and early 21st century, maybe Acceleration Facilitators are the necessary way ahead - that may not be a formal role (yeah, I made it up), but people with the ability to work in an accelerating world should be high on your list.  Acceleration Facilitators are not Gen X, Gen Y or any of the newfangled names we may be given for when we're born.  They're attitudinal based not upon when they started, but how they adapt to that world around them. 

My last point is that no-one knows what the future holds.  Technologically it may be fine to assume Microsoft or Apple has the next big thing lined up and we all know it will be the i-thingey this or that.  But the truth is the mass population probably don't know what the next big thing is - Facebook came from nowhere to change the lives of billions.  The good news is that the so called experts don't really know either so you're in good company.  I can speculate and I have some views of my own, but I'll probably be wrong (nothing new here).  The only thing I can tell you about the next big thing is that it will be coming soon.  Then the one after that will probably be sooner still.

Remember it's not just a fast-moving world, it's an accelerating one so being able to keep up now is no guarantee for the future, but your ability to adapt in that accelerating environment is vital.

Tuesday, 16 September 2014

Let designers do the design

Something that always astounds me is in the world of elearning and learning technologies is the level of amateur work that can be found.  One of the big causes for this is a reluctance to use experts or professionals and, perhaps even more disturbing, paying a professional and then ignoring their work and doing it yourself.  I can understand that those new to the world of elearning may be shocked by the costs involved and choose to try it alone or using internal resources.  But there's projects and there's projects.  If I want to put up a new fence I may feel it's worth me having a go (someone just alerted the local council by now) rather than paying someone else to do it, but if I want to put a second floor on the house or build an extension it's a step too far for me so I need to get a professional in.  Same is true of learning technologies and in one area particularly; design.  And if I'm getting someone in, surely it makes sense that I listen to them?
So I'm building an extension (note to the council: I'm not, this is hypothetical I promise) you could think the first stage is to leap in and draw up the plans, but you'd be missing an important first step - working out what you want.  Before you formalise the solution you need to look at what your needs are and what limitations you have.  It's no good me designing my three story extension if the land has conditions which prevent it from being used or my building is too close to the boundary line and of course is the extension fit for the purpose I presumably had?  Before you draw up your plan you must have some sort of need - doesn't this sound a bit like the approach to instructional design?  Pretty soon I would realise that I'm out of my depth and I'd bring in a professional to at least have the opening discussions with, let them know what I need and want.  After that information gathering and needs analysis they can then start to draft something up for me.

...and here's where the problems start.

"No, that's not what I'm after".  When you get a design it may not be exactly what you were expecting and one thing we have to realise is 'that's okay'.  If we want a design to reflect exactly how it looked in our heads, then you're probably right in thinking you don't need an expert to design it.  The problem is that unless you're a professional or remarkably have natural skill in this area you limit the final solution.  In fact you'll probably find that if you start with the solution in mind that the analysis was a waste of time too. 

For me a regular example of this is in theming an LMS.  We start out by talking to a client about what they want to use their learning environment for, what type of content, user experience etc etc.  We take into account their marketing designs, colour schemes, fonts, imagery etc etc.  The best kind of customers then step out the way and let us come up with some designs for them which should then open up a discussion so that we can narrow down and then they can choose and we build.  Easy as.  When it goes wrong it's often because they already have firmly decided what they want without taking into account how the systems work or the end user experience.  Don't get me wrong - if you're after a portal that needs to closely replicate your other systems then we realise that we're working a very limited design and the process should be fairly straight forward.  The hardest people to deal with though are the ones who don't know what they want - they just know they don't want whatever you can come up with! 

My advice here for my would-be extension or LMS design would be to approach with an open mind.  I hand over all the details and then let the designer come up with some ideas.  Again, it doesn't have to be what I would design (what would be the point?) or even something that would knock my socks off, but I should be able to 'get it'.  The next part of the design process is to look at the options and narrow down the design.  Don't go back to the start unless the designer really hasn't got it at all.  From now on it should be a simple iterative process to end up with your final design (and do try to limit the iterations and reduce your preconceptions wherever possible).  Voila house plans done!  Over to the builder but that's another story for another day. 

I mentioned earlier instructional design too.  Good instructional designers are worth their weight in gold and they are similar to good graphic designers in that they work best when you talk them through what your needs are and prevent them the information they need.  They should then work on some form of plan or storyboard for you.  It doesn't have to be exactly what you would have done (what would be the point?) or even something that would knock your socks off, but you should be able to 'get it'.  The next part of the learning design process is to look at the options and narrow down the design.  Don't go back to the start unless the instructional designer really hasn't got it at all.  From now on it should be a simple iterative process to end up with your final design (limiting iterations again).  Voila learning plans done!  Yes building is another story!

Graphical design can be something of a dark art - but a great designer really will come out with something that makes you go 'wow' every so often.  Same too with a piece of elearning - occasionally I see a piece and have that same reaction.  Whilst you're not going to get that every time with a designer approach you almost never see that kind of reaction to amateur DIY projects.

The key thing here is that if you're going to engage a professional for design purposes then you need to be receptive to their ideas and be prepared to change your mind.  If not, then do it yourself, but the 'wow' reaction isn't likely - at least not in the way you were hoping.